Best Bagels in Charlotte, NC
This is Evan's list of the best Bagels in Charlotte, NC: 5 spots. It is not a strict ranking: Evan-approved picks come first, then honorable mentions. Every spot has its address, price level and Evan's notes, and links to its menu and reviews. The guide was last updated Oct 18, 2026.
Metzger's Bakeshop✓
My preferred NYC-style bagel in Charlotte, boiled then baked like they're supposed to be. Delivery only, so plan ahead. The babka, rugelach, and black-and-white cookies are the bonus round.
Tega Cay Bagel / Rock Hill Bagel✓
Sister shops turning out great NY-style bagels south of the border. If you're in Tega Cay or Rock Hill, this is your bagel.
Jeff's Bagel Run✓
True New York-style bagels — slightly crispy crust, soft chewy center — made over a two-day process (proofed, boiled at 210°F, then baked). No sandwiches, just bagels with an extensive lineup of homemade cream cheeses (rosemary salt, cinnamon sugar, cookies and cream, and more). Limited seating, mostly grab-and-go.
New York Old School Bagel✓
A solid NYC-style bagel with a proper deli to back it up. Old school in the ways that matter.
PopUp Bagels✓
PopUp Bagels nails the New York-style bagel with a crispy exterior and soft, chewy interior, served hot and fresh with their "Grip. Rip. Dip." approach (no slicing, no toasting). The schmears are the real star: the Mac and Cheese tastes like elevated Kraft nostalgia, and the Truffle Butter is surprisingly balanced…
About this list of Bagels in Charlotte
Which Bagels spots are on Evan's list?
The list has 5 spots. It includes Metzger's Bakeshop, Tega Cay Bagel / Rock Hill Bagel and Jeff's Bagel Run, plus 2 more.
How much do these Bagels spots cost?
Google's price levels for these spots: 5 at $. More dollar signs means a pricier meal.
Where in Charlotte are they?
By ZIP code: 28277 (2), 28206 (1), 28226 (1). Each listing above shows the full street address.
This site was created with ♥ in CLT by CharlotteFoodieGuy